Click on the banner to Order the
EYES OF THE MOTHMAN film! Enter the Code
PRGHOSTS at check-out and get
$5 off Your order!
the Unexplained from Whitechapel Press
INTO THE SHADOWS
American Unsolved Mysteries & Tales of the Unexplained by Troy Taylor
The History, Mystery & Unexplained of the Prairie State
The History, Mystery & Unexplained of the
Bluegrass State by B.M. Nunnelly
A Guidebook to American Mysteries & The Unexplained by Jerry D.
MORE STRANGE HIGHWAYS
More True Stories of America's Unknown Creatures & Mysterious Happenings by Jerry D. Coleman
as the strange creature came to be called, is perhaps one of the strangest
creatures to ever grace the annals of weirdness in America. Even though this
mysterious and unsolved case has nothing to do with ghosts, it would be remiss
of me to not include it in a section of the website about the unexplained.
The weird events connected to the Mothman began on November 12, 1966 near
Clendenin, West Virginia. Five men were in the local cemetery that day,
preparing a grave for a burial, when something that looked like a “brown human
being” lifted off from some nearby trees and flew over their heads. The men
were baffled. It did not appear to be a bird, but more like a man with wings. A
few days later, more sightings would take place, electrifying the entire region.
Late in the evening of November 15, two young married couples had a very
strange encounter as they drove past an abandoned TNT plant near Point Pleasant,
West Virginia. The couples spotted two large eyes that were attached to
something that was "shaped like a man, but bigger, maybe six or seven feet
tall. And it had big wings folded against its back". When the creature
moved toward the plant door, the couples panicked and sped away. Moments later,
they saw the same creature on a hillside near the road. It spread its wings and
rose into the air, following with their car, which by now was traveling at over
100 miles per hour. "That bird kept right up with us," said one of the
group. They told Deputy Sheriff Millard Halstead that it followed them down
Highway 62 and right to the Point Pleasant city limits. And they would not be
the only ones to report the creature that night. Another group of four witnesses
claimed to see the “bird” three different times!
Another sighting had more bizarre
results. At about 10:30 on that same evening, Newell Partridge, a local
building contractor who lived in Salem (about 90 miles from Point
Pleasant), was watching television when the screen suddenly went dark.
He stated that a weird pattern filled the screen and then he heard a
loud, whining sounds from outside that raised in pitch and then ceased.
“It sounded like a generator winding up” he later stated. Partridge’s
dog, Bandit, began to howl out on the front porch and Newell went out to
see what was going on.
When he walked outside, he saw Bandit facing the hay barn, about 150 yards
from the house. Puzzled, Partridge turned a flashlight in that direction and
spotted two red circles that looked like eyes or “bicycle reflectors”. They
moving red orbs were certainly not animal’s eyes, he believed, and the sight
of them frightened him. Bandit, an experienced hunting dog and protective of his
territory, shot off across the yard in pursuit of the glowing eyes. Partridge
called for him to stop, but the animal paid no attention. His owner turned and
went back into the house for his gun, but then was too scared to go back outside
again. He slept that night with his gun propped up next to the bed. The next
morning, he realized that Bandit had disappeared. The dog had still not shown up
two days later when Partridge read in the newspaper about the sightings in Point
Pleasant that night.
One statement that he read in the newspaper chilled him to the bone. Roger
Scarberry, one member of the group who spotted the strange “bird” at the TNT
plant, said that as they entered the city limits of Point Pleasant, they saw the
body of a large dog lying on the side of the road. A few minutes later, on the
way back out of town, the dog was gone. They even stopped to look for the body,
knowing they had passed it just a few minutes before. Newell Partridge
immediately thought of Bandit, who was never seen again.
On November 16, a press conference was held in the county courthouse and the
couples from the TNT plant sighting repeated their story. Deputy Halstead, who
had known the couples all of their lives, took them very seriously. “They’ve
never been in any trouble,” he told investigators and had no reason to doubt
their stories. Many of the reporters who were present for the weird recounting
felt the same way. The news of the strange sightings spread around the world.
The press dubbed the odd flying creature “Mothman”, after a character from
the popular Batman television series of the day.
The remote and abandoned TNT plant became the lair of the Mothman in the
months ahead and it could not have picked a better place to hide in. The area
was made up of several hundred acres of woods and large concrete domes where
high explosives were stored during World War II. A network of tunnels
honeycombed the area and made it possible for the creature to move about without
being seen. In addition to the manmade labyrinth, the area was also comprised of
the McClintic Wildlife Station, a heavily forested animal preserve filled with
woods, artificial ponds and steep ridges and hills. Much of the property was
almost inaccessible and without a doubt, Mothman could have hid for weeks or
months and remained totally unseen. The only people who ever wandered there were
hunters and fishermen and the local teenagers, who used the rutted dirt roads of
the preserve as “lover’s lanes”.
Very few homes could be found in the region, but one dwelling belonged to the
Ralph Thomas family. One November 16, they spotted a “funny red light” in
the sky that moved and hovered above the TNT plant. “It wasn’t an airplane”,
Mrs. Marcella Bennett (a friend of the Thomas family) said, “but we couldn’t
figure out what it was.” Mrs. Bennett drove to the Thomas house a few minutes
later and got out of the car with her baby. Suddenly, a figure stirred near the
automobile. “It seemed as though it had been lying down,” she later
recalled. “It rose up slowly from the ground. A big gray thing. Bigger than a
man with terrible glowing eyes.”
Mrs. Bennett was so horrified that she dropped her little girl! She quickly
recovered, picked up her child and ran to the house. The family locked everyone
inside but hysteria gripped them as the creature shuffled onto the porch and
peered into the windows. The police were summoned, but the Mothman had vanished
by the time the authorities had arrived.
Mrs. Bennett would not recover from the incident for months and was in fact
so distraught that she sought medical attention to deal with her anxieties. She
was tormented by frightening dreams and later told investigators that she
believed the creature had visited her own home too. She said that she could
often hear a keening sounds (like a woman screaming) near her isolated home on
the edge of Point Pleasant.
Many would come to believe that the sightings of Mothman, as well as UFO
sightings and encounters with “men in black” in the area, were all related.
For nearly a year, strange happenings continued in the area. Researchers,
investigators and “monster hunters” descended on the area but none so famous
as author John Keel, who has written extensively about Mothman and other
unexplained anomalies. He has written for many years about UFO’s but dismisses
the standard “extraterrestrial” theories of the mainstream UFO movement. For
this reason, he has been a controversial figure for decades. According to Keel,
man has had a long history of interaction with the supernatural. He believes
that the intervention of mysterious strangers in the lives of historic
personages like Thomas Jefferson and Malcolm X provides evidence of the
continuing presence of the “gods of old”. The manifestation of these elder
gods comes in the form of UFO’s and aliens, monsters, demons, angels and even
ghosts. He has remained a colorful character to many and yet remains respected
in the field for his research and fascinating writings.
Keel became the major chronicler of the Mothman case and wrote that at least
100 people personally witnessed the creature between November 1966 and November
1967. According to their reports, the creature stood between five and seven feet
tall, was wider than a man and shuffled on human-like legs. Its eyes were set
near the top of the shoulders and had bat-like wings that glided, rather than
flapped, when it flew. Strangely though, it was able to ascend straight up “like
a helicopter”. Witnesses also described its murky skin as being either gray or
brown and it emitted a humming sound when it flew. The Mothman was apparently
incapable of speech and gave off a screeching sound. Mrs. Bennett stated that it
sounded like a “woman screaming”.
John Keel arrived in Point Pleasant in December 1966 and immediately began
collecting reports of Mothman sightings and even UFO reports from before the
creature was seen. He also compiled evidence that suggested a problem with
televisions and phones that began in the fall of 1966. Lights had been seen in
the skies, particularly around the TNT plant, and cars that passed along the
nearby road sometimes stalled without explanation. He and his fellow researchers
also uncovered a number of short-lived poltergeist cases in the Ohio Valley
area. Locked doors opened and closed by themselves, strange thumps were heard
inside and outside of homes and often, inexplicable voices were heard. The James
Lilley family, who lived just south of the TNT plant, were so bothered by the
bizarre events that they finally sold their home and moved to another
neighborhood. Keel was convinced that the intense period of activity was all
And stranger things still took place..... A reporter named Mary Hyre, who was
the Point Pleasant correspondent for the Athens, Ohio newspaper the Messenger,
also wrote extensively about the local sightings. In fact, after one very
active weekend, she was deluged with over 500 phone calls from people who saw
strange lights in the skies. One night in January 1967, she was working late in
her office in the county courthouse and a man walked in the door. He was very
short and had strange eyes that were covered with thick glasses. He also had
long, black hair that was cut squarely “like a bowl haircut”. Hyre said that
he spoke in a low, halting voice and he asked for directions to Welsh, West
Virginia. She thought that he had some sort of speech impediment and for some
reason, he terrified her. “He kept getting closer and closer to me, “ she
said, “ and his funny eyes were staring at me almost hypnotically.”
Alarmed, she summoned the newspaper’s circulation manager to her office and
together, they spoke to the strange little man. She said that at one point in
the discussion, she answered the telephone when it rang and she noticed the
little man pick up a pen from her desk. He looked at it in amazement, “as if
he had never seen a pen before.” Then, he grabbed the pen, laughed loudly and
ran out of the building.
Several weeks later, Hyre was crossing the street near her office and saw the
same man on the street. He appeared to be startled when he realized that she was
watching him, turned away quickly and ran for a large black car that suddenly
came around the corner. The little man climbed in and it quickly drove away.
By this time, most of the sightings had come to an end and Mothman had faded
away into the strange “twilight zone” from which he had come... but the
story of Point Pleasant had not yet ended. At around 5:00 in the evening on
December 15, 1967, the 700-foot bridge linking Point Pleasant to Ohio suddenly
collapsed while filled with rush hour traffic. Dozens of vehicles plunged into
the dark waters of the Ohio River and 46 people were killed. Two of those were
never found and the other 44 are buried together in the town cemetery of
The Silver Bridge (Photo
Courtesy of William Wright)
On that same tragic night, the James Lilley family (who still lived near the
TNT plant at that time) counted more than 12 eerie lights that flashed above
their home and vanished into the forest.
The collapse of the Silver Bridge made headlines all over the country and
Mary Hyre went days without sleep as reporters and television crews from
everywhere descended on the town. The local citizens were stunned with horror
and disbelief and the tragedy is still being felt today.
During Christmas week, a short, dark-skinned man entered the office of Mary
Hyre. He was dressed in a black suit, with a black tie, and she said that he
looked vaguely Oriental. He had high cheekbones, narrow eyes and an unidentified
accent. He was not interested in the bridge disaster, she said, but wanted to
know about local UFO sightings. Hyre was too busy to talk with him and she
handed her a file of related press clipping instead. He was not interested in
them and insisted on speaking with her. She finally dismissed him from her
That same night, an identically described man visited the homes of several
witnesses in the area who had reported seeing the lights in the sky. He made all
of them very uneasy and uncomfortable and while he claimed to be a reporter from
Cambridge, Ohio, he inadvertently admitted that he did not know where Columbus,
Ohio was even though the two towns are just a few miles apart.
So who was Mothman and what was behind the strange events in Point Pleasant?
Whatever the creature may have been, it seems clear that Mothman was no hoax.
There were simply too many credible witnesses who saw “something”. It was
suggested at the time that the creature may have been a sandhill crane, which
while they are not native to the area, could have migrated south from Canada.
That was one explanation anyway, although it was one that was rejected by
Mothman witnesses, who stated that what they saw looked nothing like a crane.
But there could have been a logical explanation for some of the sightings. Even
John Keel (who believed the creature was genuine) suspected that a few of the
cases involved people who were spooked by recent reports and saw owls flying
along deserted roads at night. Even so, Mothman remains hard to easily dismiss.
The case is filled with an impressive number of multiple-witness sightings by
individuals that were deemed reliable, even by law enforcement officials.
But if Mothman was real... and he truly was some unidentified creature that
cannot be explained, what was behind the UFO sightings, the poltergeist reports,
the strange lights, sounds, the “men in black” and most horrifying, the
collapse of the Silver Bridge?
John Keel believes that Point Pleasant was a “window” area, a place that
was marked by long periods of strange sightings, monster reports and the coming
and going of unusual persons. He states that it may be wrong to blame the
collapse of the bridge on the local UFO sightings, but the intense activity in
the area at the time does suggest some sort of connection. Others have pointed
to another supernatural link to the strange happenings, blaming the events on
the legendary Cornstalk Curse that was placed on Point Pleasant in the 1770's.
(Click Here to Discover
the details about the Cornstalk Curse)
And if such things can happen in West Virginia, then why not elsewhere in the
country? Can these “window” areas explain other phantom attackers,
mysterious creatures, mad gassers and more that have been reported all over
America? Perhaps they can, but to consider this, we have to consider an even
more chilling question... where will the next “window” area be? It might be
of benefit to study your local sightings and weird events a little more
carefully in the future!
© Copyright 2001 by Troy Taylor. All Rights Reserved.
Sources and Recommended Bibliography:
Unexplained! by Jerome Clark (1999)
The Mothman Prophecies by John Keel (1975)
The Complete Guide to Mysterious Beings by John Keel (1970 / 1994)
Our Haunted Planet by John Keel (1971)
Disneyland of the Gods by John Keel (1988)
The Silver Bridge by Gray Barker (1970)
Mysterious America by Loren Coleman (1983 / 2000)
to the American Hauntings Home Page!